Best Restaurants in New Carlisle, IN

Here’s the America’s Best Online list of the best Restaurants in New Carlisle, IN. Kate O'Connor's Irish Pub got the current top restaurant ranking for New Carlisle. Closely following #1 are Ambrosia Banquet & Catering, Bobbie's Dock Side Grille, Happy Joes Kasik Bar and MOSER'S AUSTRIAN CAFE. After reading the top ten restaurants in New Carlisle be sure to check out the Indiana Restaurants nearby in cities such as Hamlet.

Top 10 Restaurants in New Carlisle, IN

  1. Kate O'Connor's Irish Pub
    415 E Michigan St., New Carlisle, Indiana 46552, USA
     • 574-654-8114
    Unrated

  2. Ambrosia Banquet & Catering
    32981 Marvel Ln, New Carlisle, IN 46552, USA
     • 574-654-3490
    Unrated

  3. Bobbie's Dock Side Grille
    7038 N Chicago Rd, New Carlisle, IN 46552, USA
     • 574-654-0388
    Unrated

  4. Happy Joes Kasik Bar
    7896 N Walker Rd, New Carlisle, Indiana 46552, USA
     • 574-654-3901
    Unrated

  5. MOSER'S AUSTRIAN CAFE
    127 E. MICHIGAN ST., New Carlisle, Indiana 46552, USA
     • 574-654-0086
    Unrated

  6. Moser's Michigan Street Cafe
    51024 Timothy Rd, New Carlisle, IN 46552, USA
     • 574-654-8466
    Unrated

  7. New Carlisle Bakery
    125 E Michigan, New Carlisle, Indiana 46552, USA
     • 574-654-8400
    Unrated

  8. Stevetty's Pizzeria
    7766 E Emery Rd, New Carlisle, IN 46552, USA
     • 574-654-7471
    Unrated

  9. Still
    117 E Michigan St, New Carlisle, Indiana 46552, USA
     • 574-654-3994
    Unrated

  10. The Diner
    601 W Michigan St, New Carlisle, IN 46552, USA
     • 574-654-7603
    Unrated


Top Restaurants Near New Carlisle

  • Down & Under Pub Corporation (Hamlet, IN)
    11.2 miles from New Carlisle
  • Sixth & 35 Cafe & Mini Mart (Hamlet, IN)
    11.2 miles from New Carlisle
  • Waymire's Corner Tap (Hamlet, IN)
    11.2 miles from New Carlisle
  • The Hamlet Cafe (Hamlet, IN)
    11.2 miles from New Carlisle
  • Tweety's Cafe (Hamlet, IN)
    11.2 miles from New Carlisle