Best Restaurants in Bayville, NY

Here’s the America’s Best Online list of the best Restaurants in Bayville, NY. Wall's Wharf got the current top restaurant ranking for Bayville. Closely following #1 are Steve's Pier 1, Breakers Restaurant, Pine Island Grill and Ship Wreck Tavern. After reading the top ten restaurants in Bayville (and the honorable mentions including Ralphs Pizza) be sure to check out the New York Restaurants nearby in cities such as Mill Neck, Locust Valley, Oyster Bay, East Norwich and Glen Cove.

Top 10 Restaurants in Bayville, NY

  1. Wall's Wharf
    18 Greenwich Ave, Bayville, NY 11709
     • 516-628-9696

  2. Steve's Pier 1
    33 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709
     • 516-628-2153

  3. Breakers Restaurant
    12 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709
     • 516-628-9690
    Unrated

  4. Pine Island Grill
    333 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709
     • 516-628-3000
    Unrated

  5. Ship Wreck Tavern
    10 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709
     • 516-628-2628
    Unrated

  6. Bridge Marina
    40 Ludlam Ave,Bayville,NY,11709
     • 516-628-8688
    Unrated

  7. Gus Pizza
    362 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709-1638
     • 516-628-9679
    Unrated

  8. Mill Creek Tavern
    275 Bayville Ave,Bayville,NY,11709
     • 516-628-2000
    Unrated

  9. Soundside Cafe
    10 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709-1601
     • 516-628-8050
    Unrated

  10. C-Side Deli Catering
    44 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709-1657
     • 516-628-3747
    Unrated

Honorable Mentions for Restaurants in Bayville

  • Ralphs Pizza
    16 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709
     • 516-628-2260

Top Restaurants Near Bayville

  • Japanese Stroll Garden (Mill Neck, NY)
    1.7 miles from Bayville
  • Locust Valley Deli (Locust Valley, NY)
    3 miles from Bayville
  • Mario's Pizza (Oyster Bay, NY)
    3.5 miles from Bayville
  • Rothmann's Steakhouse (East Norwich, NY)
    4.6 miles from Bayville
  • Andros Grill Pizza & Gyro (Glen Cove, NY)
    5 miles from Bayville