Best Restaurants in Oyster Bay, NY

Here’s the America’s Best Online list of the best Restaurants in Oyster Bay, NY. Mario's Pizza got the current top restaurant ranking for Oyster Bay. Closely following #1 are Village Gourmet Catering, Canterbury Ales Oyster Bar and Grill, Mill River Inn Inc and Nino's Pizza. After reading the top ten restaurants in Oyster Bay (and the honorable mentions including Salumeria Tredici) be sure to check out the New York Restaurants nearby in cities such as East Norwich, Mill Neck, Syosset, Locust Valley and Bayville.

Top 10 Restaurants in Oyster Bay, NY

  1. Mario's Pizza
    253 Pine Hollow Rd, Oyster Bay, NY 11771
     • 516-922-9111

  2. Village Gourmet Catering
    19 Summit St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771
     • 516-922-5572

  3. Canterbury Ales Oyster Bar and Grill
    46 Audrey Ave,Oyster Bay,NY,11771
     • 516-922-3614
    Unrated

  4. Mill River Inn Inc
    160 Mill River Rd,Oyster Bay,NY,11771
     • 516-922-7768
    Unrated

  5. Nino's Pizza
    25 E Main St,Oyster Bay,NY,11771
     • 516-922-0434
    Unrated

  6. Mid China
    175 Pine Hollow Rd,Oyster Bay,NY,11771
     • 516-624-0008
    Unrated

  7. Anthony's Pizzeria & Cafe
    94 South St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771, USA
     • 516-922-4279
    Unrated

  8. La Stella Pizzeria
    342 Lexington Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771, USA
     • 516-922-2023
    Unrated

  9. Periwinkles Catering Corporation
    6 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771, USA
     • 516-922-5700
    Unrated

  10. Sajoma Grocery
    21 E Main St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771
     • 516-922-2047
    Unrated

Honorable Mentions for Restaurants in Oyster Bay

  • Salumeria Tredici
    249 Pine Hollow Rd, Oyster Bay, NY 11771-4707
     • 516-922-3505

Top Restaurants Near Oyster Bay

  • Rothmann's Steakhouse (East Norwich, NY)
    1.3 miles from Oyster Bay
  • Japanese Stroll Garden (Mill Neck, NY)
    1.9 miles from Oyster Bay
  • Village Hero (Syosset, NY)
    3.1 miles from Oyster Bay
  • Locust Valley Deli (Locust Valley, NY)
    3.5 miles from Oyster Bay
  • Wall's Wharf (Bayville, NY)
    3.5 miles from Oyster Bay